Your Kid and the Supreme Court


Hi Reader,

🇺🇸 Nothing says The Fourth of July like the Supreme Court deciding all their cases before summer recess! This year there was a lot of discussion around education. I broke down 4 important cases so you can understand how this will impact your child in school.


Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond (Religious Charter Schools)

What happened?
Oklahoma’s virtual charter board approved St. Isidore of Seville, a Catholic virtual school, to receive state funding: a first in U.S. history. The state attorney general sued, arguing that using public dollars for religious instruction violated Oklahoma’s constitution and the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. Read more about it here

Outcome / what it means:
The U.S. Supreme Court delivered a 4–4 deadlock, with Justice Barrett recused. That split leaves in place the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s decision blocking St. Isidore, but it doesn’t set a nationwide precedent. This tie reveals how deeply divided the issue is, and it signals that the question of religious charter schools is far from settled. We’re likely to see this case like this again.

Natalie’s Perspective: In my opinion, charter schools should not be religious. Even though they are not the same as public schools, they are funded by public money. Religious institutions already save a ton of money each year by not paying taxes, so I would be disappointed to see religious schools receive tax money knowing our public schools already operate on a shoe string budget.


A.J.T. v. Osseo Area Schools, Independent School District No. 279 (Student Discrimination)

What happened? A student with severe morning seizures couldn't attend school until noon. Her parents asked for night classes or flexible options, but the district refused. When they brought a lawsuit leadership hadn’t been made aware of the issue, so it wasn’t a valid discrimination case.

Outcome / what it means: The court ruled in favor of A.J.T., deciding that students with disabilities don't need to prove a school intended to discriminate in order to bring a claim. This aligns their rights with disability protections in other settings. Read more here.

Natalie’s Perspective: Intent shouldn’t be the bar. If a student is being excluded, even passively, that's discrimination. Families shouldn't have to prove bad intentions just to get support. We live in an ableist world, and I’d like to see children with disabilities get support from their school as an absolute bare minimum.

I used to teach children after hours that had medical disabilities keeping them from school. My school district funded and organized this. In a day and age where we are worried about chronic absenteeism and children dropping out of high school, districts should be working hand in hand with families to get kids to school!


Mahmoud v. Taylor (LGBTQ+ Books in School)

What happened? In Montgomery County, Maryland, elementary schools introduced several LGBTQ‑inclusive books. Initially, parents could opt their children out, but in March 2023, the Board removed both opt-out options and notifications. A group of parents from diverse religious backgrounds sued, arguing this forced their children to participate in instruction that conflicts with their religious beliefs

Outcome / what it means: On June 27, 2025, the Supreme Court (6–3) ruled that the Board’s no-opt-out policy likely burdens parents’ free exercise of religion and that they’re entitled to a preliminary injunction reinstating opt-outs and notice.

The case referenced to make this decision? Wisconsin v. Yoder, a case that allowed Amish parents to remove their children from school under the age of 16. Read more here

Natalie’s Perspective: Religious Freedom and public school will always clash. This will not be the last time we see this issue in the Supreme Court. I’ve covered books with LGBTQ+ themes extensively in my banned book series. These story books tend to be adorable and validating for all family structures. It’s wild to me the case just above this one redefines what discrimination is…but does not apply to LGBTQ+ rights. These children deserve to be seen and appreciated in school too.

This weekend I’m going to officiate my best friend’s wedding in San Francisco. She’s marrying another woman who is the perfect match for her. I’ll be damned if anyone makes their future children feel anything less than valid in this world.


Trump v. CASA de Maryland, Inc. (Immigration Status and Public Schools)

What happened? CASA, an immigrant advocacy group, sued over a Trump-era rule requiring states to share immigration status with federal authorities including in public schools. The concern: families pulling their kids from school out of fear.

Outcome / what it means: Not decided yet. If the court sides with Trump, it could undermine protections that keep schools safe and accessible for all kids, regardless of immigration status.

Natalie’s Perspective: No child should be afraid to go to school. Making children fearful of going to school impedes their human right to get an education. Families need to trust that school is a safe, welcoming place.


So, I'd love to know what you're thinking. Any cases you've been watching closely? Will any of these cases impact your family? Let me know!

If you appreciate pieces like this, you can buy me a coffee here. Thanks for supporting Primary Focus. 🩷

What's New?

🇺🇸 Halfway: It's wild to me we are halfway through the year! I'm taking some time this week to do some business reflecting planning. Primary Focus has had some big wins this year, so I need to sit down and reflect to strategize for the second half of the year. Later this week I'll be officiating my best friend's wedding. I'm so happy she's found her person. If you've got officiating tips- send them my way!

Things I Love

📚 fast read: I read the book Yellowface by R.F. Kuang. It's a page turner and a little spooky at times. Really interesting commentary on where we are in society.

☀️ super dupe!: I'm a big fan of Super Goop's unseen sunscreen...but it's a little expensive. I've been using ELF's sunscreen and it's great for my workouts.This $14 version feels lightweight and is sweat resistant.

Have a happy and safe Fourth of July!

Primary Focus Newsletter

Learn about the latest news in education and tips to help your kids thrive in elementary school. Delivered to your inbox every Tuesday. Primary Focus was founded by Natalie Parmenter, a former kindergarten teacher to guide parents through elementary school. We provide information that is often common knowledge to teachers but is not widely known among parents. Primary Focus is dedicated to enlightening parents on all things elementary school so their children can thrive.

Read more from Primary Focus Newsletter
Two people sitting at a table playing a game

"If I'm not there, it won't get done" Man Child by Sabrina Carpenter 💡 One Ticket left to tomorrow's Kindergarten School Talk Workshop ! Hello Reader, Take a second and think about how you organize your day. Some people are methodical spending time every day maintaining their list. Others do a once weekly (or monthly) reset and let everything go in between. The hardest part of time management is just how much there is to do! Work, home, school, meals, fitness plans, clothing, and then add how...

Natalie and her husband Mike take a selfie in front of a sign that says WCNC Charlotte

"Wasting the day away..." Margaritaville by Jimmy Buffet 🔥 New Dates! Come to the Kindergarten School Talk Workshop Mon July 14 or Weds July 16. Early Bird Discount Expires Monday! Code: EARLY10 Sign up here Hey Reader, Imagine your child ended third grade knowing all their times tables. They worked so hard and aced their multiplication quizzes each week. But then... when they return after summer break they are suddenly struggling in math. Their new fourth grade teacher sends home a note...

a young boy running through a sprinkle of water

"Out for summer, out 'til fallWe might not come back at all" School's Out by Alice Cooper 😭😭😭 My June workshop sold out! Thank you so much for buying tickets and spreading the word. I've added a second date Mon June 23. Get your tickets here- save $5 with code FRIENDS5EVER Hi Reader, The end of the school year is a big deal. It marks growth, effort, and a whole lot of learning (in and out of the classroom!). But let’s be honest: it’s also a really busy time. I'm sharing 5 simple, repeatable...